And there's fans who agree with David Abramowitz that it is Talmudic Discussion With Swords. This page has it as "A romantic Talmudic discussion with ass-kicking", which covers all the bases. "They're Talmudic questions. How long do you have to keep a promise? What is the difference between honor and vanity? Is morality and justice fixed by time, or only in time and place, or does it exist, the same morality - true morality; and true justice. Justice, does it exist in the seventeenth century and that it's the same in the twentieth century. Those kinds of questions. They were great fun to write about."

If I had discovered this last year instead of now, I would totally have lobbied my Jewish Studies advisor to let me write my thesis on Talmudic Discussion In Highlander, if only to enjoy the resultant fit of apoplexy.